Netflix's Top 10 Shows: What's Hot and What's Not?
Updated Oct. 21, 2025, 3:28 p.m. ET
Netflix’s ever-expanding library is a treasure trove of entertainment, from gripping original series to beloved classics from networks like HBO and NBC. But with so much to choose from, how do you know what’s worth your time? Fear not! Every week, Netflix releases a list of the 10 most-watched shows, and we’re here to break it down for you. But here’s where it gets controversial: Are these shows truly the best, or just the most hyped? Let’s dive in and find out.
This week, Monster: The Ed Gein Story continues its reign at the top, while Boots climbs to No. 2, and the new season of The Diplomat secures the No. 3 spot. Below, you’ll find the full list, complete with insights and links to our reviews. And this is the part most people miss: We’ll also tell you which shows are worth binge-watching and which ones you can skip.
While you’re here, don’t forget to check out our other Netflix lists, like the Top 10 Movies on Netflix, the Best Movies on Netflix, and What’s New on Netflix this month. Happy streaming!
1. Ms. Rachel: Season 2
Kids’ shows are a Netflix staple, and Ms. Rachel is the latest sensation. After the Cocomelon craze, this friendly, interactive series has captured young hearts. But here’s the kicker: Is it just another fad, or does it truly stand out? DECIDER’s Joel Keller praises its engaging approach, ensuring kids participate rather than passively watch. Stream it and decide for yourself!
2. Ms. Rachel: Season 1
The first season of Ms. Rachel introduced the world to this YouTube-turned-Netflix star, who teaches kids about reading and speech. Controversial question: Are educational shows like this the future of children’s programming, or do they oversimplify learning? Let us know in the comments!
3. Wayward
Starring Mae Martin and Toni Collette, this thriller follows students at Tall Pines Academy who uncover dark secrets after an escape attempt. But here’s where it gets divisive: Is it a gripping mystery or just another teen drama with a dark twist? Keller highlights the strong performances but notes the balance between dark and darkly funny.
4. No One Saw Us Leave
Based on Tamara Trottner’s memoir, this drama explores a father’s vengeful kidnapping of his children after discovering his wife’s infidelity. Bold claim: This isn’t just a thriller—it’s a deeply human story. But does it handle its heavy themes with care, or does it veer into melodrama? You be the judge.
5. Monday Night Raw: 2025
WWE fans, rejoice! Raw: 2025 brings live wrestling action to Netflix every Monday. Controversial take: Is this a brilliant move to attract sports fans, or does it dilute Netflix’s focus on scripted content? Share your thoughts below!
6. Is It Cake? Halloween
This spooky spin-off of the hit baking competition sees contestants crafting hyperrealistic cakes to fool celebrity judges. Fun fact: It’s as delightful as it sounds, but is it just a gimmick, or does it add something new to the genre? Let’s debate!
7. Love is Blind: Season 9
Denver singles take on Netflix’s love experiment in this reality dating series. But here’s the harsh truth: Keller admits the show might be losing its charm. Are we all just too jaded, or has the formula run its course? Sound off in the comments!
8. The Diplomat: Season 3
Keri Russell leads this political drama, now joined by The West Wing alums Allison Janney and Bradley Whitford. Bold prediction: With such a stellar cast, this season could be the best yet. But does it live up to the hype? Stream it and tell us what you think.
9. Boots
Set in the ’90s, this dramedy follows a gay teenager who joins the Marines. Controversial interpretation: While it’s entertaining, is it just another ‘misfits in the military’ story, or does it offer fresh perspectives? Keller praises its characters, but we want to hear from you!
10. Monster: The Ed Gein Story
Charlie Hunnam portrays the infamous serial killer in Ryan Murphy’s anthology series. Thought-provoking question: Does this series glorify violence, or does it provide a nuanced look at a disturbing figure? Keller applauds its historical context, but what’s your take?
Final Question for You: Which of these shows are you most excited to watch, and which ones do you think are overrated? Let’s get the conversation started in the comments!
